Categories: Recaps

American Horror Story: Asylum premiere review: Crazy, crazier, grossed out!

American Horror Story is back! I don’t know if the premiere was just so good, or just utterly crazy. But it certainly left me impressed. I think the amount of different angles in the episode was a bit too much. Aliens, a serial killer, a crazy nun, a crazy doctor, an armless horny guy and the thing that took his arm. Am I forgetting anything else? Anyway, I think the main storyline has the potential to be great, but there was too much going on to enjoy the main storyline.

I’m not trying to gross anyone out, but you know that face you had while watching this picture (to the right). Yeah, that was my face for most of the episode. So now we’re on the same page!

I think the “lovers” storyline wasn’t really necessary. It wouldn’t really have made any difference. Yeah okay, now we know that thousands of people died in there. So what? I think they’re aiming for the reverse-storytelling of last year. (Flashbacks to the past and then the main storyline, with now flashforwards to the future and then the main storyline.) Adam Levine got to play his dream role of a horny husband, so everybody’s happy!

Almost everybody’s back for the second season, but that’s not necessarily a bad thing. Lange flourishes as the head bitch/nun in charge, with the ’60s timeframe as her best accessory. It was clever thinking, for tackling the issues like the gay couple in this specific time frame. I’m not sure how I feel about the alien storyline. That was the “this is too much” part from the episode.

For the most part, this episode was about setting up the whole world of the Briarcliff. We’ve got to see a glimpse of everything really. Even though the head nun seems kind of crazy for locking up a gay journalist or an innocent who’s being accused of being a serial killer (who happens to be married to a coloured girl.). For now, it seems like she’s doing this for her faith in the Lord and not because she’s not right in the mind. That’s the difference between her and the loony doctor. She’s doing this for ‘God’ and he’s doing it in the name of science. That’s the part I’m excited for, to see that dualism!

I didn’t know what to expect from American Horror Story: Asylum, and I’m left with mixed feelings. Do I want to keep watching a season with more than a dozen different storylines? Probably not, but I’m confident that this was just a bad case of pilot-itis.

View Comments

  • Oh no doubt it, this is classic Ryan Murphy. He can string together a couple of good episodes but by the time a second season rolls around, everything is insanely batshit and defies logic. It can be entertaining (Nip/Tuck) or strangely deadly dull (Glee). Not sure where this one really falls yet..

    • I thought this time it could be different because of the different storyline and such. I'll wait an see

  • Well, I can tell you that things will definitely get insanely batshit, but with a terrifying logic that will spin everything into a very dark place. Just suffice to say that all is not what it seems in the world of Briarcliff.
    Michael Goi
    Director of Photography
    "American Horror Story"

Share
Published by
Guinevere De Raymaeker

Recent Posts

On the precipice of Moonlighting’s downward trajectory

ABC's detective hit Moonlighting was one of the best TV show's of all time —…

5 years ago

‘The 100’ Star Marie Avgeropoulos Says Octavia Blake Doesn’t Need A Man (Or Woman) To Be Happy! Season 6 Is About Forgiving Her Sins

Previously Published on Fan Fest News...  For six seasons on The 100, actress Marie Avgeropoulos…

6 years ago

Becoming Josephine: ‘The 100’ Star Eliza Taylor Says Goodbye To Clarke… For Now

Previously Published on Fan Fest News...  It seems The 100 fans have gotten their own…

6 years ago

TV shows are not several mini-movies

I was browsing Reddit after the clock struck midnight on New Year's Eve (or what…

7 years ago

10 of my favorite shows of 2018

It's a little late, but I wanted to share a few shows I liked this…

7 years ago

Hulu’s ‘The Looming Tower’ star Mark Hildreth talks human heroism, and selfishness in US History

Mark Hildreth is a jack of all trades, with an undeniable passion for entertaining. Viewers…

8 years ago