Wow. It was brutal. Just like that, we’re down to four now after cutting Friday Night Lights, Supernatural, The X-Files (in dead last), and Lost.

Now the competition for our summer rewatch/review is between Breaking Bad, Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Game of Thrones, and Pretty Little Liars. Make sure to cast your vote for which show you want to watch with me and all of us this summer (from the beginning) below. Tomorrow, the list will be down to two, and on Saturday we’ll have a winner!

Poll closes Friday May 11th at 10:00am EDT.